This guide covers 3 ice cream shop options in Cape Coral. Guests rate them 4.5 out of 5 on average. Most of them are in Hancock, so that is the area to start with.

All Ice cream shop in Cape Coral

Mangia Bene Big Slice

4.3 821 reviews

Mangia Bene Big Slice is a family-owned Italian restaurant and pizzeria located in Cape Coral, Florida, serving authentic Italian cuisine since 1999. The restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere and a menu full of favorites like pizza, pasta, chicken, and homemade desserts. They are known for their traditional Italian recipes, which are crafted with love and care by the Salvatore family. Mangia Bene Big Slice has been serving New York-style pizza in Cape Coral since 1999, offering big slices, fresh ingredients, and plenty of options for the whole family. Their menu features a variety of Italian favorites, including pasta, sandwiches, salads, and classic pizzeria dishes. They also offer catering services for parties, office lunches, and local events. Whether you're in the mood for a quick slice or a hearty meal, Mangia Bene Big Slice has something for everyone. The restaurant is proud to serve Cape Coral with New York-style pizza and Italian favorites since 1999. They take pride in making every order fresh and giving their customers the kind of service that feels personal. From weeknight dinners to casual lunches and weekend takeout, they want every visit to feel easy, satisfying, and worth repeating. Their goal is to provide a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere for their customers, making them feel like part of the family.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–9 PM
  • SundayClosed

Jeremiah’s Italian Ice

4.8 348 reviews

Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a frozen dessert brand that offers a variety of treats, including Italian Ice, Soft Ice Cream, and Jelati. Their Italian Ice is a refreshing frozen treat made fresh daily in each location, with 24 flavors available daily, and 40 rotating flavors throughout the year. They also offer a range of Soft Ice Cream flavors and decadent Layer-Ins to create unique flavor combinations. Jeremiah's Italian Ice is committed to providing flavorful experiences for their customers, with a focus on authenticity, quality, and community involvement. They strive to embody six core values: Cool, Bold, Genuine, Vibrant, Generous, and Strategic, which guide their business decisions and interactions with customers. Their menu features a wide variety of treats, including Flavorites, Jelati Cakes, and Hop-Away Treats, which can be customized to suit individual tastes. Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a franchised business, with over 130 locations in 11 states, and a franchise program that invites new owners to join the "Frog Squad." They are committed to giving back to their communities through charitable partnerships, fundraising events, and community involvement. Their goal is to provide a fun and welcoming experience for customers, while also promoting a culture of authenticity, quality, and community involvement.

Opening hours
  • Monday12–10 PM
  • Tuesday12–10 PM
  • Wednesday12–10 PM
  • Thursday12–10 PM
  • Friday12–11 PM
  • Saturday12–11 PM
  • Sunday12–10 PM

Happy Sun Ice Cream Cape Coral

4.4 191 reviews

Happy Sun Ice Cream is an ice cream shop that offers a tempting selection of tasty homemade ice cream, popsicles, natural juices, antojitos, and specialties. They have over 50 flavors of all-natural, gluten-free homemade ice cream, popsicles, slushies, and specialty snacks. Their menu features a diverse range of flavors, including traditional ice creams and unique Mexican treats like Paletas and Mangonadas. Happy Sun Ice Cream prides itself on using all-natural, premium ingredients in their products, which are made fresh in-store every day. They believe that creative combinations, consistently fresh, and high-quality ingredients are the key to making their ice cream, popsicles, and specialties delicious. Their staff enjoys seeing customers again and again, and they cater to people of all ages who want to stop by to relax and enjoy their treats. They offer a welcoming atmosphere, with a vibrant and colorful decor that makes it a popular spot for casual outings. Happy Sun Ice Cream has three locations in Cape Coral and Fort Myers, offering a convenient and accessible destination for locals and visitors alike. Their menu is diverse, with options ranging from traditional ice creams to unique Mexican treats like Paletas and Mangonadas. They also offer natural juices, slushies, and snacks, making them a great destination for families and individuals looking for a sweet treat.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–9 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–9 PM