This guide covers 11 italian restaurant options in Fort Myers. Guests rate them 4.5 out of 5 on average. Most of them are spread across Fort Myers Downtown Commercial District, Reflection Lakes, so those are the areas to start with.

All Italian restaurant in Fort Myers

Terra Nostra Ristorante

4.5 996 reviews

Terra Nostra Ristorante is a fine Italian restaurant located in Fort Myers. It is renowned for serving some of the best Italian classics and finest steaks and seafood. The restaurant features a modern Martini & Wine Bar and a welcoming Terrace perfect for exterior dining. Terra Nostra offers a variety of dining experiences suitable for different occasions, including family or friends, business or pleasure. The restaurant's atmosphere is designed to cater to special occasions, and it has a VIP Club that provides exclusive benefits to its members. The club includes invitations to wine tasting events and special Winemakers' Dinners. Terra Nostra is a Wine Spectator Award winner, showcasing its expertise in fine wine and exquisite cuisine. The restaurant's menu is elegant and its wine list is award-winning, with a variety of high-quality options available. The restaurant also offers gift cards and gift boxes for purchase, making it a great option for special occasions and gifts.

Opening hours
  • Monday4–10 PM
  • Tuesday4–10 PM
  • Wednesday4–10 PM
  • Thursday4–10 PM
  • Friday4–10 PM
  • Saturday4–10 PM
  • Sunday4–10 PM

Mona Lisa Italian Restaurant

4.3 841 reviews

Mona Lisa Italian Restaurant is a family-owned and operated restaurant established in 1979. It offers a variety of Italian dishes, including pasta, pizza, and appetizers. The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner, as well as late night, and features a fun and relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant's menu includes a range of options, such as build-your-own pizzas, calzones, and pasta dishes. Some of the specialties include chicken marsala, chicken mona lisa, and eggplant parmesiana. The restaurant also offers a selection of salads, soups, and desserts, including cannoli, tiramisu, and zeppole. Mona Lisa Italian Restaurant is located in Fort Myers, Florida, and is open for karaoke seven nights a week. The restaurant can be contacted by phone at (239) 747-7325 or through its location on the Slice app.

Opening hours
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4 PM–2 AM
  • Wednesday4 PM–2 AM
  • Thursday4 PM–2 AM
  • Friday4 PM–2 AM
  • Saturday4 PM–2 AM
  • Sunday4 PM–2 AM

McGregor Pizza & Deli

4.7 1,258 reviews

McGregor Pizza Company is a locally-owned and operated pizzeria with two locations in Fort Myers, Florida. It offers a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas, as well as salads, subs, and Italian desserts. The company's menu features a range of options, including gluten-free and vegetarian choices. McGregor Pizza Company's menu is designed to cater to a wide range of tastes and dietary needs. The company's pizzas are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and cooked in a brick oven to give them a crispy crust and a flavorful taste. The menu also features a variety of specialty pizzas, including the "McGregor Margherita" and the "Naughty Stromboli." In addition to its pizza menu, McGregor Pizza Company also offers a range of salads, subs, and Italian desserts. McGregor Pizza Company is committed to providing its customers with a high-quality dining experience. The company's staff is friendly and welcoming, and its locations offer a comfortable and relaxed atmosphere. McGregor Pizza Company also offers delivery and takeout services, making it easy for customers to enjoy its delicious food from the comfort of their own homes. With its wide range of menu options and commitment to quality and customer service, McGregor Pizza Company is a great choice for anyone looking for a delicious and satisfying meal.

Opening hours
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–9:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–9:30 PM
  • Sunday12–8 PM

Mastello Ristorante & Steakhouse

4.5 466 reviews

Mastello is a fine dining Italian steakhouse serving Prime, aged meats, Wagyu, international wines, and craft cocktails. It offers a wide variety of dishes including American Wagyu, Fine-Aged Meats, and seafood from raw to professionally prepared sea scallops to a signature Risotto di Mare. The restaurant is located in Fort Myers, just minutes from Barbara B. Mann theater, and has a stylish cocktail bar with over 100 wine selections. Mastello's menu features a range of options, including Old Fashioneds and Espresso Martinis, as well as a selection of sipping "After Dinner Delights" from Bourbons to trending Tequilas. The restaurant serves Prime, American Wagyu, Fine-Aged Meats, and seafood, making it a destination for those looking for high-quality dining in South West Florida. Mastello is known for its excellent service and atmosphere, making it a popular choice for special occasions and events. Mastello's target audience is individuals looking for a fine dining experience in a stylish and sophisticated setting. The restaurant is suitable for a wide range of occasions, from birthdays and anniversaries to corporate events and holiday parties. With its high-quality menu and exceptional service, Mastello is a great choice for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience.

Opening hours
  • Monday4–10 PM
  • Tuesday4–10 PM
  • Wednesday4–10 PM
  • Thursday4–10 PM
  • Friday4–10 PM
  • Saturday4–10 PM
  • Sunday4–10 PM

Il Pomodoro Italian Restaurant

4.3 571 reviews

Il Pomodoro is an authentic Italian restaurant in Fort Myers. It offers classic Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients in a relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant caters to a wide range of customers, including individuals and groups, and provides various dining options such as reservations, online ordering, and catering services. Il Pomodoro's menu features a variety of Italian cuisine, including pasta dishes, sandwiches, and more. The restaurant has received positive reviews from customers, with many praising its service, food, and atmosphere. Some reviewers have mentioned the generous portions and high-quality ingredients used in the dishes. The restaurant also caters to special events such as birthday parties and holiday gatherings. Il Pomodoro's catering services allow customers to bring the restaurant's Italian cuisine to their events. The restaurant offers customized catering packages and menus to suit different needs and preferences. By choosing Il Pomodoro, customers can enjoy authentic Italian food in a relaxed and welcoming setting. The restaurant's catering services are available for a range of events, from small gatherings to large corporate events.

Opening hours
  • Monday4:30–8 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–8 PM
  • Friday11 AM–8 PM
  • Saturday4–8 PM
  • Sunday4–8 PM

Citrola’s on College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.6 1,152 reviews

Citrola's On College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a business that serves Italian cuisine, offering a variety of dishes such as pizzas, pastas, entrees, subs, salads, and appetizers. The restaurant is located in Fort Myers, Florida, and its menu includes traditional pasta dishes, a wine list, and daily lunch specials. Citrola's On College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a family-friendly establishment that welcomes customers of all ages. The business is built on the belief that providing the best possible cuisine is essential for a great dining experience. To achieve this, they use only the freshest ingredients, bake their own homemade bread daily, and hand-toss their pizzas with fresh toppings and special sauce. This commitment to quality has earned Citrola's On College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria a reputation for serving the best Italian food in south west Florida. Citrola's On College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria caters to a wide range of occasions, including birthday parties, corporate events, and wedding festivities. Their catering services offer a variety of options that can be tailored to fit any occasion, from casual gatherings to more formal events. The restaurant also offers private parties and reservations for special occasions, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors to Fort Myers.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–9 PM
  • Saturday3–9 PM
  • Sunday3–9 PM

Citrola’s Italian Restaurant on McGregor

4.4 681 reviews

Citrolas is a family-owned Italian restaurant that has been serving the community in Grand Junction, Colorado, since 1993. It combines two beloved local kitchens into one welcoming space, offering a blend of morning coffee, satisfying lunch, and authentic dinner options. The restaurant features relaxed espresso service, hearty Italian entrées, and a casual or elegant-rustic atmosphere. Citrolas specializes in modern Italian cuisine, with a focus on fresh daily preparation and authentic flavors. The menu includes a variety of pasta dishes, salads, and pizza options, as well as desserts and espresso. The restaurant is vegetarian-friendly, offers vegan options, and has gluten-free choices available. Citrolas also offers takeout and catering services for events and gatherings. Citrolas is a popular dining destination in Grand Junction, with a 4.0 rating on Tripadvisor based on 213 reviews. The restaurant is known for its friendly service, delicious food, and cozy atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Citrolas is a great place to enjoy a satisfying meal and experience the warmth and hospitality of a family-owned Italian restaurant.

Opening hours
  • Monday4–9 PM
  • Tuesday4–9 PM
  • Wednesday4–9 PM
  • Thursday4–9 PM
  • Friday4–9 PM
  • Saturday4–9 PM
  • Sunday4–9 PM

CIBO Italian Restaurant & Bar

4.7 894 reviews

Cibo is a family-owned Italian restaurant located in Fort Myers, Florida. It has been in business since 2004, renowned for its culinary excellence and internationally inspired dishes created with local fresh ingredients. The restaurant is known for its wonderful Weekend Specials, featuring very popular and highly requested "Old Favorites" and New Exciting Seasonal Creations. Cibo is well known across Fort Myers for its selection of fine wines, focusing on varietals from California and Italy. Cibo offers a variety of Mediterranean/Italian cuisine, including pastas, steaks, seafood, desserts, beer, cocktails, and wine. The restaurant has a unique mix of classic dishes and seasonal specialties, with a focus on using fresh, local ingredients. The menu includes a range of appetizers, salads, and entrees, as well as a selection of fine wines and cocktails. Cibo is known for its exceptional service, with a team of highly-trained, experienced, and dedicated staff. The restaurant has received widespread attention from customers and food critics alike, with numerous reviews and testimonials praising its food, service, and atmosphere. Cibo has been recognized as one of the top-rated restaurants in Fort Myers, with a 4.7-star rating on various review platforms. The restaurant's owner, Craig Komatz, has been praised for his dedication to his business and his commitment to providing an exceptional dining experience for his customers.

Opening hours
  • Monday4–9 PM
  • Tuesday4–9 PM
  • Wednesday4–9 PM
  • Thursday4–9 PM
  • Friday4–10 PM
  • Saturday4–10 PM
  • Sunday4–9 PM

Carrabba’s Italian Grill

4.6 3,602 reviews

Carrabba's is a restaurant chain that specializes in serving authentic Italian cuisine. The company was founded in 1986 by Johnny Carrabba and Damian Mandola, and it has since grown to become a prominent player in the hospitality industry. With a focus on wood-fired grilled specialties and handmade pasta dishes, Carrabba's offers a menu that is inspired by traditional Italian recipes and prepared with fresh ingredients in open exhibition kitchens. Carrabba's menu features a variety of dishes, including signature items such as Chicken Bryan, Pollo Rosa Maria, and Wood-Fire Grilled Steak and chops. The company also offers a range of pasta dishes, including classic Italian fare prepared with fresh ingredients. In addition to its dine-in service, Carrabba's also offers Carside Carryout and Delivery, making it a convenient option for customers who want to enjoy a delicious Italian meal in the comfort of their own homes. Carrabba's operates both company-owned and franchise restaurants, with locations across North America, Europe, and South America. The company has a commitment to providing exceptional service and a welcoming atmosphere, with a focus on creating a memorable dining experience for its customers. With a strong presence in both business-to-business and business-to-consumer markets, Carrabba's has established itself as a leader in the hospitality industry.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–10 PM
  • Friday11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–9 PM

Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza

4.4 4,441 reviews

Capone's Coal Fired Pizza is a unique dining establishment located in Downtown Fort Myers, specializing in coal-fired pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches. The restaurant is themed around the 1920s and 1930s gangster era, particularly focusing on the infamous Al Capone, providing guests with an immersive experience filled with historical memorabilia. Capone's offers a variety of dining options, including lunch, dinner, and happy hour, as well as takeout and delivery services. Capone's Coal Fired Pizza is known for its coal-fired pizzas, which are cooked to perfection in a 900-degree oven, giving them a distinctive char and smoky flavor. The restaurant also serves a range of pasta dishes, sandwiches, and salads, making it a great option for those looking for a casual dining experience. Capone's has received praise for its welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious food, making it a popular spot in downtown Fort Myers. Capone's Coal Fired Pizza is a great option for those with gluten intolerance, as they offer a gluten-free menu and take steps to avoid cross-contamination in their kitchen. The restaurant has received positive reviews from the gluten-free community, with many praising their efforts to accommodate gluten-free diners. Despite some negative reviews, Capone's Coal Fired Pizza remains a popular spot in downtown Fort Myers, offering a unique dining experience and delicious food to its customers.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–10 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–9 PM