This guide covers 16 italian restaurant options in Indianapolis. Guests rate them 4.5 out of 5 on average. Most of them are spread across Mile Square, Fletcher Place, Meridian-Kessler, so those are the areas to start with.

All Italian restaurant in Indianapolis

Vito Provolone’s

4.7 1,148 reviews

Vito Provolone's is a family-owned Italian restaurant on the south side of Indianapolis. It offers traditional Italian cuisine, including classic pastas, pizzas, and house favorites like Chicken Marsala and Vito's Vodka Sauce. The restaurant prides itself on simple cuisine, brilliantly prepared, and invites guests to enjoy a great Italian feast. Vito's menu includes appetizers, entrees, pasta, pizza, and desserts, as well as a selection of red and white wine, specialty and import beers. Vito's has been serving the community for over 30 years, with a reputation for attentive and knowledgeable service in a relaxed and informal atmosphere. The restaurant is open Monday through Thursday from 4 to 9 pm and Friday and Saturday from 4 to 9:30 pm, and offers take-out, delivery, and catering services. Vito's is also a popular spot for special occasions and events, with a cozy atmosphere and a wide range of menu options to suit every taste.

Opening hours
  • Monday4–9 PM
  • Tuesday4–9 PM
  • Wednesday4–9 PM
  • Thursday4–9 PM
  • Friday4–9:30 PM
  • Saturday4–9:30 PM
  • SundayClosed

Sam’s Square Pie

4.8 435 reviews

Toast is a restaurant technology company that offers a comprehensive platform for restaurants to improve operations, increase sales, and create a better guest experience. The platform provides point of sale (POS) and management system capabilities, including offline mode, 24/7 support, sales forecasting, chargeback prevention, mobile payments, and nested modifiers. Toast's online ordering system allows customers to place orders via a website, mobile app, or other digital platforms, and the company provides domain management and subdomain options for restaurants to customize their online presence. Toast's online ordering system is designed to turn hungry searches into repeat orders and fuel lasting growth, with no commissions or hidden fees. The system allows for seamless digital ordering experiences for both guests and staff, and Toast provides rewards, offers, and updates sent straight through a restaurant's branded app or SMS text messages. Toast's online ordering system is integrated into the restaurant's POS, allowing for a seamless experience and increasing sales. The system also provides data insights and connection through the API to other tools that restaurants use. Toast is a trusted partner for restaurants, providing a true business partner experience. The company's commitment to innovation and willingness to partner with operators helps restaurants streamline operations, empower their teams, and focus more on hospitality. Toast's expanding ecosystem and API connections enable restaurants to optimize their operations and create a better guest experience. With a focus on helping restaurants work smarter, Toast provides a platform that is designed for what happens mid-shift, including offline mode, sales forecasting, and chargeback prevention.

Pronta Pizzeria

4.7 692 reviews

Pronta Pizzeria is a casual eatery that offers a variety of fast-food options such as pasta, sandwiches, and artisanal pizza in a relaxed setting. Pronta Pizzeria has received high praise for its flavorful and almost supernatural crust of their pizzas, as well as the inviting atmosphere that makes you want to linger. The quick service and fresh, house-made ingredients have left many patrons impressed. The pizzeria's menu includes a range of options, including giant New York-style pizzas made quickly, as well as calzones and garlic knots. Pronta Pizzeria also offers catering services for groups of all sizes, with convenient pickup, delivery, or catering options available. The menu is designed to be appealing to a wide range of customers, from families to offices and events. Pronta Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated business, with a husband-and-wife team running the shop. They are committed to using high-quality ingredients and making their pizzas fresh every day. The pizzeria is located in downtown Indianapolis, near the Indiana Convention Center, Lucas Oil Stadium, and the Indiana Statehouse, making it a convenient option for visitors and locals alike.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–6 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–6 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–6 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–6 PM
  • Friday11 AM–6 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–4 PM
  • SundayClosed

Piada Italian Street Food

4.3 1,569 reviews

Piada Italian Street Food is a fast-casual restaurant chain that specializes in serving hand-rolled Italian piadas, fresh chopped salads, and tossed pastas made to order. The menu features a variety of options, including pasta dishes, salads, and street sides, with prices ranging from around $8 to over $13. Customers can customize their meals with a range of toppings and sauces. Piada Italian Street Food offers a casual dining experience with a focus on quick service and quality ingredients. The restaurant chain has multiple locations across the US, with a presence in 38 locations, and has a strong online presence with a mobile app and rewards program. Customers can order online or through the app, and the restaurant offers a loyalty program that rewards customers for repeat purchases. The chain also has a charitable initiative, Piada Gives, which donates 1% of sales to a designated charity. Overall, Piada Italian Street Food is a popular choice for those looking for a quick and flavorful meal with a focus on Italian cuisine. The restaurant's menu offers a range of options, and the chain's commitment to quality and customer service has earned it a 3.8-star rating on Yelp based on over 8,300 reviews. With its fast-casual atmosphere and customizable menu options, Piada Italian Street Food is a great choice for those in the mood for a quick and satisfying meal.

  • 8601 River Crossing Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46240
  • Washington Township
  • (317) 581-9955
  • mypiada.com
  • Today: 10:45 AM–10 PM
Opening hours
  • Monday10:45 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday10:45 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday10:45 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday10:45 AM–10 PM
  • Friday10:45 AM–10 PM
  • Saturday10:45 AM–10 PM
  • Sunday10:45 AM–10 PM

The Old Spaghetti Factory

4.3 4,298 reviews

OSF Digital is a Salesforce-first consulting partner helping organizations become agentic enterprises. The company was founded in 2003 and has since grown to serve more than 2,000 customers from capability centers across North America, Latin America, EMEA, and Asia-Pacific. OSF Digital offers advisory, implementation, and managed services, focusing on strategy-led thinking, trusted data, and disciplined execution. OSF Digital helps organizations navigate technology complexity and modernize their operations toward measurable outcomes. The company delivers agentic transformation through a structured, gated journey, starting with one high-value process and then building a Center of Excellence in parallel. This approach enables organizations to scale their agentic capability on their own and move from a successful pilot to governed, enterprise-scale production. OSF Digital builds agentic solutions on trusted data and enterprise-grade governance, with role-based access, full audit history, and human oversight where it matters. OSF Digital is an AI-forward, data-driven, Salesforce-centric consulting services company that helps global organizations decide where agents are worth deploying before anything gets built. The company offers a range of services, including advisory, implementation, and managed services, and has expertise in areas such as AI, data, and trusted data. With a global scale and boutique attention, OSF Digital delivers results that scale and move organizations beyond AI experimentation, orchestrating humans and AI agents across real business processes.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–10 PM
  • Saturday12–10 PM
  • Sunday12–9 PM

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.3 3,474 reviews

Olive Garden is a prominent American casual dining restaurant chain established in 1982, specializing in Italian-American cuisine. As a subsidiary of Darden Restaurants, Inc., it operates within the broader hospitality sector. The company has built a significant presence across the United States, focusing on delivering a consistent dining experience. Its operational model emphasizes family-friendly dining and a broad appeal to diverse customer demographics. The brand is recognized for its signature dishes and commitment to service quality. Olive Garden offers a variety of Italian-American dishes, with specific items like pasta, salads, and breadsticks forming core components of its menu. The company's menu is designed to appeal to a broad range of customers, including families, casual diners, and Italian cuisine enthusiasts. Olive Garden's menu includes a range of options, from classic Italian recipes to modern twists on traditional dishes. The company's commitment to quality and consistency has earned it a loyal customer base. Olive Garden has a significant presence across the United States, with nearly 900 restaurants and over 99,000 employees. The company's annual sales exceed $4.9 billion, making it one of the leading restaurant chains in the country. Olive Garden's commitment to quality and customer service has earned it a reputation as a reliable and trustworthy dining option. The company's focus on family-friendly dining and its broad appeal to diverse customer demographics have made it a staple in many communities.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–10 PM
  • Friday11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–10 PM

Napolese Pizzeria

4.4 431 reviews

Napolese is an artisanal pizzeria founded by six-time James Beard Foundation semifinalist Martha Hoover in 2010. It is about artfully made pizza and stone hearth baking. The seasonal menu paired with incredible service makes for a world-class pizza experience. Napolese uses the finest ingredients available, carefully sourcing cheeses, meats, and local farm produce grown specifically for the restaurant. The menu is paired with incredible service, making it a world-class pizza experience. The restaurant offers private events and reservations for special occasions, making it a great choice for corporate meetings, holiday gatherings, or parties. Napolese has multiple locations in Indianapolis, IN, and is known for its delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant has received high ratings on review platforms such as Yelp and OpenTable, with customers praising its excellent service and delicious food. Reviewers have also noted the restaurant's commitment to using high-quality ingredients and its welcoming atmosphere, making it a great choice for those looking for a great pizza experience.

Opening hours
  • Monday5–9 PM
  • Tuesday5–9 PM
  • Wednesday5–9 PM
  • Thursday5–9 PM
  • Friday5–9 PM
  • Saturday5–9 PM
  • Sunday5–9 PM

Monti Aperitivo & Cucina

4.8 129 reviews

Monti Boutique is a fashion company that specializes in providing high-quality clothing materials and accessories for women, men, and children. For over 40 years, its brand stands for elegance and research, a landmark and not-to-be-missed destination of the fashion world in the historical buildings of Via Fantaguzzi, Cesena. They claim that all the products they offer are carefully selected from well-reputable fashion industries around the world. Monti Boutique offers a wide range of products, including clothing, accessories, and home decor items. Their products are designed to showcase the company's distinctive identity, ensuring that customers make an unforgettable impact in a world full of networking possibilities. The company has a strong presence in the fashion industry, with four shops and 15 window stores, making it a popular destination for fashion enthusiasts. Monti Boutique has received positive reviews from customers, with many praising their customer service, product quality, and overall shopping experience. On Trustpilot, Monti Boutique has a rating of 559, with many customers praising the company's ability to deliver high-quality products and provide excellent customer service. The company's commitment to customisation, ease of use, and innovation has also been praised by customers, making it a popular choice for those looking for a unique and memorable shopping experience.

Opening hours
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4–11 PM
  • Wednesday4–11 PM
  • Thursday4–11 PM
  • Friday4–11 PM
  • Saturday4–11 PM
  • SundayClosed

Mama Carolla’s

4.7 2,817 reviews

Mama Carolla's is an upscale Italian restaurant located in a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa in Indianapolis, Indiana. It offers a full bar and a garden, making it a pleasant destination for a date night or a family gathering. The restaurant is known for its exceptional service and delicious Italian dishes, including gluten-free options. Mama Carolla's features a gluten-free penne pasta, and every entree and pasta dish is made to individual order with every sauce, allowing for a high degree of customization. The restaurant's menu includes a variety of traditional Italian dishes, such as manicotti and lasagna, as well as more modern creations. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate, with a fireplace and period lighting fixtures that maintain the historical charm of the villa. Mama Carolla's has received numerous awards and recognition for its exceptional dining experience, including Indianapolis Monthly's "The 25 Essential Eats of Indy" and TripAdvisor's "Highest Rated Italian Restaurant in Indianapolis." The restaurant accepts reservations for groups of six or more, and offers take-out and delivery options for those who prefer to dine at home.

Opening hours
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday5–9:30 PM
  • Wednesday5–9:30 PM
  • Thursday5–9:30 PM
  • Friday5–9:30 PM
  • Saturday5–9:30 PM
  • SundayClosed

Maggiano’s Little Italy

4.5 4,075 reviews

Maggiano's Little Italy is a popular restaurant chain that offers authentic Italian-American cuisine in a family-style setting. It has 48 locations across the United States and has received an average rating of 3.7 from 42,856 reviews on Yelp. The chain is known for its generous portions, delicious food, and excellent service. Maggiano's menu features a wide range of Italian classics, including pasta dishes, seafood, meat, and vegetarian options. Maggiano's has received mixed reviews from customers, with some praising the chain's food and service, and others criticizing its high prices and inconsistent quality. Some reviewers have noted that the chain's service can be slow and inattentive, while others have praised the friendly and attentive servers. In terms of food, Maggiano's has received praise for its pasta dishes, including its famous lasagna, and its seafood options, including its branzino and chicken fettuccine. However, some reviewers have noted that the chain's food can be hit-or-miss, and that the quality can vary depending on the location. Maggiano's is a family-friendly restaurant chain that offers a welcoming atmosphere and a wide range of menu options. It is a popular choice for special occasions, such as birthday celebrations and anniversaries, and is also a great option for families with children. The chain offers a variety of promotions and deals, including its popular "Lunch & Dinner" menu, which features a variety of options at a lower price point. Maggiano's also offers a loyalty program and a rewards card, which can help customers save money and earn rewards.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–10 PM
  • Friday11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–9 PM