This guide covers 15 pizza restaurant options in New York. Guests rate them 4.6 out of 5 on average. Most of them are in Manhattan, so that is the area to start with.

All Pizza restaurant in New York

Zia Maria Little Italy

4.6 6,932 reviews

Zia Maria-Little Italy is a hospitality business that specializes in authentic Italian cuisine. Established in 2016, the business offers a range of traditional Italian dishes, including fresh pasta, wood-fired pizza, and artisanal pizzas. The menu is designed to capture the vibrant diversity of authentic Italian cuisine, with a focus on using the finest seasonal ingredients and traditional imports. The business is run by Chef Enrico, who is known for his daily ritual of hand-rolling, cutting, and tossing fresh pasta from scratch in the front window. The restaurant has two locations in New York City, one in Little Italy and another in Chelsea. The business offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, with a focus on family-style dining and sharing meals with others. Zia Maria-Little Italy is a popular destination for special occasions, including corporate gatherings, rehearsal dinners, and milestone birthdays. The business offers private event spaces and customizable menus to ensure that every event is memorable and seamless. With a focus on authentic Italian cuisine and a welcoming atmosphere, Zia Maria-Little Italy is a great choice for anyone looking for a unique and delicious dining experience.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–10 PM
  • Friday11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–10 PM

Song’ E Napule

4.7 2,698 reviews

Song'E Napule Pizzeria & Trattoria is a restaurant that serves Italian cuisine. It offers a variety of dishes, including pizzas, and has a cozy and traditional atmosphere. The restaurant can accommodate a limited number of customers at once to ensure a personalized dining experience. The restaurant has a strong reputation, with a 4.6-star rating based on 590 reviews. Customers have praised the friendly staff, delicious food, and authentic Italian experience. The restaurant is also known for its inclusivity, catering to customers with dietary restrictions such as dairy and nut allergies. Song'E Napule Pizzeria & Trattoria is located at 106 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, and can be reached by phone at (201) 347-9339. The restaurant is a popular destination for those looking for authentic Italian food in the Rutherford area.

Opening hours
  • Monday12–11 PM
  • Tuesday12–11 PM
  • Wednesday12–11 PM
  • Thursday12–11 PM
  • Friday12–11 PM
  • Saturday12–11 PM
  • Sunday12–11 PM

Sofia’s of Little Italy

4.6 3,799 reviews

Sofia's is an Italian restaurant in New York City's Little Italy, offering a chef-led menu of handmade pastas, fresh pizza, and seasonal Italian dishes in a welcoming neighborhood atmosphere with live music. The restaurant provides catering services for various occasions, including birthday parties, holiday events, corporate gatherings, and wedding festivities. Their catering packages are designed to fit any budget, allowing customers to focus on enjoying the event without worrying about the logistics. The menu features a range of options, including fresh, delicious pizza and a variety of Italian dishes made with high-quality ingredients. Sofia's has received positive reviews from customers, who praise the restaurant's food, service, and atmosphere. Reviewers have complimented the staff's attentiveness and kindness, the freshness and taste of the dishes, and the overall welcoming vibe of the restaurant.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–11 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–11 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–11 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–11 PM
  • Friday11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–11 PM

Rubirosa

4.7 7,699 reviews

Rubirosa is a family-run Italian-American restaurant and pizzeria located in New York's Nolita neighborhood. It was founded on the principles of original family recipes that have delighted customers for decades. The restaurant's menu is inspired by the finest ingredients and old-world know-how, offering a range of Italian specialties perfect for enhancing everyday meals at home. Rubirosa's menu features a variety of dishes, including pasta, pizza, and other Italian-American classics. The restaurant's pasta sampler and vodka sauce gift set is a popular choice among customers, who rave about the quality and flavor of the dishes. The restaurant's menu is designed to cater to a range of tastes and dietary requirements, with options for gluten-free and vegetarian diners. Rubirosa's commitment to using the finest ingredients and traditional cooking methods ensures that every dish that leaves the kitchen is a delicious and satisfying experience. Rubirosa's reputation for serving some of the best pizza in New York City is well-deserved. The restaurant's pizza is made with a thin crust that can handle a generous amount of sauce, and the toppings are carefully selected to complement the flavors of the pizza. The restaurant's menu is designed to offer something for everyone, whether you're in the mood for a classic Italian dish or something more adventurous. With its commitment to quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods, Rubirosa is a must-visit destination for anyone looking for a delicious and authentic Italian meal.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–11 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–11 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–11 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–11 PM
  • Friday11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–11 PM

Pazza Notte

4.4 3,313 reviews

Pazza Notte is an Italian eatery that serves artisanal pasta, authentic wood-fired pizza, and exquisite desserts. The business offers a unique dining experience that blends time-honored Italian traditions with contemporary American flair. It is located in the heart of Manhattan and Sacramento, and its menu features a variety of dishes crafted from the freshest ingredients. The restaurant's philosophy is to use the best ingredients possible, do as little to them as necessary, and let the quality and flavors shine through. Its recipes are inspired by Italian and American comfort food, as well as the owner's family traditions. The business prides itself on its simple yet elegant atmosphere, great music, and killer cocktails, making it a warm and welcoming destination for guests. Pazza Notte is a popular destination for those seeking exceptional Italian cuisine, with glowing reviews from locals and visitors alike. Guests rave about the quality of the food, the relaxed yet elegant atmosphere, and the overall excellent service. The business is known for its exceptional value for the price, making it a reliable choice for a night out.

Opening hours
  • Monday12–9:45 PM
  • Tuesday12–10:15 PM
  • Wednesday12–10:15 PM
  • Thursday12–10:15 PM
  • Friday12–10:15 PM
  • Saturday12–10:15 PM
  • Sunday11:30 AM–9:45 PM

Osteria Barocca

4.7 3,623 reviews

Osteria Barocca is a restaurant that offers authentic Italian cuisine in the Little Italy neighborhood of New York City. The restaurant is located in a neighborhood with a strong Italian-American influence and serves traditional Italian dishes, likely using fresh and high-quality ingredients. It is designed to provide an immersive experience for customers, with an atmosphere that evokes the culture and traditions of Italy. Osteria Barocca targets customers who are looking for an authentic Italian dining experience in a specific neighborhood, possibly locals and tourists who are familiar with the Italian-American culture.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–10 PM
  • Friday11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–10 PM

Norma

4.6 1,760 reviews

Norma Gastronomia Siciliana is an authentic Sicilian restaurant in New York City. It brings traditional Sicilian cuisine to the heart of the city, offering a unique dining experience. With a mission to bring true culture to America, Norma Gastronomia Siciliana focuses on traditional cuisine, familial service, and an intimate ambiance. The restaurant is an organic space reflective of nature-inspired cuisine, and its menu features authentic Sicilian dishes, exclusively Sicilian wines, and a warm, intimate atmosphere inspired by Sicily. Norma Gastronomia Siciliana's journey began with its inaugural opening in Murray Hill in 2016, and it has since expanded to include locations in Hell's Kitchen and Turtle Bay. Each location maintains its unique charm, with soft lighting, curated music, impeccable service, and authentic Sicilian-inspired cuisine. The restaurant's menu features traditional Sicilian dishes, such as pasta, risotto, and arancini, all made with high-quality ingredients and a focus on using locally sourced ingredients. The restaurant's chef, Salvatore Fraterrigo, is a passionate cook who grew up in Trapani, Sicily, and has a deep understanding of Sicilian cuisine. Norma Gastronomia Siciliana is a great option for those looking for authentic Sicilian cuisine in New York City. Its menu features a wide range of traditional Sicilian dishes, and its intimate atmosphere makes it a great setting for date nights, family dinners, or friendly gatherings. The restaurant's commitment to using locally sourced ingredients and its focus on traditional Sicilian cuisine make it a great choice for those looking for a unique and authentic dining experience.

Opening hours
  • Monday12–10 PM
  • Tuesday12–10 PM
  • Wednesday12–10 PM
  • Thursday12–10 PM
  • Friday12–10:30 PM
  • Saturday12–10:30 PM
  • Sunday12–10 PM

Nizza

4.7 2,324 reviews

Nizza is a cozy Italian restaurant located on 9th Avenue in Hell's Kitchen, New York. It serves classic Italian cuisine, including pizza, pasta, soup, and gluten-free options. The restaurant offers weekend brunches and wine Wednesdays, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. Nizza's menu is designed to highlight the best of Ligurian comfort food, with fresh pasta made in-house and handmade pizza from a brick oven. The restaurant also offers a wide variety of gluten-free dishes, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a cozy feel that makes customers feel right at home. Nizza is a quintessential Italian restaurant, serving locals, visitors, and pre-theater enthusiasts since 2007. The restaurant's name is inspired by the French seaside city of Nice, and the menu is designed to transport customers to the coastal regions of Italy. With its cozy atmosphere and delicious Italian cuisine, Nizza is a must-visit destination for anyone looking for a great meal in Hell's Kitchen.

Opening hours
  • Monday12–10 PM
  • Tuesday12–10 PM
  • Wednesday11:30 AM–11 PM
  • Thursday12–11 PM
  • Friday12–11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–10 PM

Marcellino

4.6 2,577 reviews

Marcellino is an Italian restaurant located in the heart of Little Italy, New York, offering authentic Italian cuisine and warm hospitality. The restaurant serves traditional dishes made with fresh ingredients and classic techniques, including pizzas, pastas, and other Italian favorites. It has received positive reviews for its delicious food, attentive service, and cozy atmosphere, making it a popular choice for both locals and tourists. Marcellino's menu features a range of options, including homemade pastas, pizzas, and traditional Italian dishes from every region in Italy. The restaurant also offers a selection of wines and handcrafted cocktails, making it a great spot for a night out with friends or a romantic dinner. The service is attentive and knowledgeable, with staff members who are happy to guide customers through the menu and make recommendations. Marcellino has a 4.1-star rating on TripAdvisor and 4.0-star rating on Yelp, indicating a high level of customer satisfaction. Reviewers have praised the restaurant's authentic Italian cuisine, attentive service, and cozy atmosphere, with many noting that it is a must-visit destination for anyone looking for a authentic Italian dining experience in New York City.

Opening hours
  • Monday12–11 PM
  • Tuesday12–11 PM
  • Wednesday12–11 PM
  • Thursday12–11 PM
  • Friday12 PM–12 AM
  • Saturday12 PM–12 AM
  • Sunday12–11 PM

La Piazza New York

4.8 430 reviews

La Piazza is an Italian restaurant chain that offers authentic Italian dining experiences in various locations. The company was founded on the principles of tradition, quality, and warm hospitality, bringing the flavors of Italy to the heart of the city. La Piazza's menu features a curated selection of Italian seafood dishes, classic pasta, wood-fired favorites, and seasonal specialties, all prepared with time-honored recipes and fresh ingredients. La Piazza's restaurants are designed to provide an elevated yet welcoming experience for guests, with a focus on authentic Italian food, attentive service, and a welcoming ambiance. The company offers private dining options for small or large groups, with flexible spaces suited for intimate dinners or larger gatherings. Guests can make dinner reservations through the company's online system or by phone, and the team works to accommodate preferred times, group sizes, and special requests. La Piazza serves a variety of seafood dishes, including shrimp, calamari, and signature pasta, all paired with authentic Italian flavors. The company's menu is designed to satisfy a wide range of tastes, from simple comforts to refined entrées. Whether dining with family, planning an event, or exploring new flavors, La Piazza invites guests to enjoy a meal that feels both comforting and memorable.

Opening hours
  • Monday11 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–10 PM
  • Friday11 AM–10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–10 PM
  • Sunday11 AM–10 PM